The Verdict blog
Data stories about what gets written online and what it actually adds. Built every week from Verdict's own numbers; every story is scored by Verdict before it goes out, and the score is shown.
The AI-twin gap, week of 26 October 2026The AI twin gap, week 44: first-hand pieces won by 40 points, familiar ones by none
Human essays beat their AI twins in 7 of 10 pairs this week, by a mean of 23.0 points. Almost all of that margin came from five pieces that held information a model could not have had.
Verdict on this piece: 83
The Echo Index, week of 26 October 2026The Echo Index: Hacker News rewards builders, mostly
Three in four of the week's most-read Hacker News essays added something new. The ones that didn't were nearly as popular.
Verdict on this piece: 87
What's actually new, week of 26 October 2026This week's most original Hacker News essays all describe something their authors made
Of 40 widely read essays scored for the week of 26 October 2026, the five that added the most were build logs, experiments and shop-floor accounts. The median was 69.5.
Verdict on this piece: 85
Also published in Expulp HQ at xpulp.com/c/hq. Subscribe: RSS.